Cream of Earl Grey (Genuine Tea) Pyramid Tea Bag | Honest Review

What Is Cream of Earl Grey?

Cream of Earl Grey is a variation of traditional Earl Grey tea.

Like classic Earl Grey, it features bergamot. The difference is the addition of natural vanilla flavour, which softens the citrus edge and adds a subtle sweetness without any sugar.

The result is a more rounded and approachable tea.

View product page: Cream of Earl Grey by Genuine Tea

Origin & Background

• Region: Dimbula, Sri Lanka
• Tea Type: Black tea
• Format: Pyramid tea bags

Dimbula teas are known for their bright and lively character, which pairs well with bergamot and vanilla.

Brewing Method

• 1 pyramid tea bag per 240 ml
• Water temperature: 95°C
• Steep time: 4 minutes

The pyramid tea bags make this very easy to prepare. No measuring or extra tools are needed.

This is a beginner-friendly tea with consistent results.

Taste, Aroma & Mouthfeel

• Aroma: Fresh and bright with noticeable bergamot and soft vanilla
• Taste: Smooth, slightly sweet, with a fresh and strong profile
• Finish: Clean, with lingering citrus and creamy notes

Compared to a traditional Earl Grey:

• Smoother than classic Earl Grey
• Less bitter than most black teas

The flavour has a fresh lift that can feel similar to mint, while still staying within the Earl Grey profile.

The vanilla softens the sharper citrus notes, making it easier to drink daily.

Versatility

This tea works well beyond a simple cup.

• Great base for a London Fog latte
  View London Fog recipe
• Can be used in desserts like muffins or cupcakes
  View Earl Grey muffins recipe

Brewing Flexibility

• Forgiving steep time
• No special equipment needed
• Consistent results with tea bags

This makes it ideal for both beginners and daily routines.

Price & Value

• $9.99 for 15 tea bags
• Approx. $0.67 per cup

The price is fair for the quality and convenience. Loose leaf tea may offer slightly better value, but this format prioritizes ease and consistency.

Best Time to Drink

Since this is a black tea, it contains caffeine.

It works best in the morning or early afternoon when you want a gentle energy boost.

Brand Note: Genuine Tea

Genuine Tea is committed to ethical sourcing and sustainability.

• Plant-based, biodegradable tea bags
• 1% of proceeds donated to the Canadian Mental Health Association

Learn more about Genuine Tea's charitable initiative

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Smooth and balanced flavour
• Natural sweetness without sugar
• Very easy to prepare
• Versatile (latte, desserts)
• Ethical and sustainable brand

Cons

• Slightly less value than loose leaf tea
  

Who This Tea Is For

This tea is a good fit if you:

• Enjoy Earl Grey but want something smoother
• Prefer slightly sweet, creamy profiles
• Want a quick and easy tea
• Like making tea-based drinks

Less ideal if you:

• Prefer strong, traditional Earl Grey
• Only drink loose leaf tea

Final Verdict

This is one of the most enjoyable and easy-to-drink teas available at Happy Fox.

The combination of bergamot and vanilla creates a smooth, balanced cup that works well on its own or in recipes.

The ease of preparation and the brand’s ethical approach add to its overall value.

Final Rating: 4.5 / 5